Justin Baldoni Granted Access to Blake Lively–Taylor Swift Texts
A major development has emerged in the legal battle surrounding the production of It Ends With Us. On June 18, 2025, U.S. District Judge Lewis J. Liman ruled that Justin Baldoni, who directed and starred in the film, is permitted to obtain private text messages exchanged between Blake Lively and Taylor Swift, as long as they relate to the movie or the ongoing lawsuit—despite Blake Lively’s bid to keep those messages confidential. los40.com+12people.com+12pagesix.com+12
⚖️ Why It Matters
Evidence relevance: Baldoni’s legal team argues these texts are material to Lively’s claims of sexual harassment and retaliation on set—messages that might shed light on what was discussed about working conditions, creative decisions, or potential outside influences. en.wikipedia.org+8pagesix.com+8eonline.com+8
Protective order imposed: While the court approved the request, it also enforced a strict protective order to prevent leaks and public exposure of the conversations. indiatoday.in
Taylor Swift’s involvement: Although a subpoena for Swift to testify was previously issued in May and later dropped, the judge emphasized that texts between Lively and Swift could illuminate Lively’s narrative—especially since Lively herself indicated Swift was aware of on-set issues. pagesix.com+15en.wikipedia.org+15eonline.com+15
The Legal Chess Game
NewsfeedBites | devafrika | hoopladigitall | Sportdynasti | wheeloffortuneonline.co
The feud began when Lively filed a December 2024 complaint accusing Baldoni and his production company of creating a hostile work environment and retaliating against her after she raised concerns—leading Baldoni to countersue for defamation, seeking $400 million. His countersuit was dismissed in June 2025. pagesix.com+10vulture.com+10eonline.com+10
Baldoni had previously tried to subpoena Swift—claiming Lively involved her and husband Ryan Reynolds to sway production decisions—but withdrew when Swift’s team stated she had no involvement beyond licensing a song. Nonetheless, the judge ruled that the texts remain relevant. en.wikipedia.org+1eonline.com+1
Fallout in Celebrity Circles
The legal entanglement has reportedly put strain on Swift and Lively’s long-standing friendship. Sources close to Swift suggest she feels betrayed by being pulled into the dispute. en.wikipedia.org+15pagesix.com+15thesun.co.uk+15
What Comes Next
Discovery phase continues: Baldoni may review the relevant texts under strict confidentiality.
Court trial set for March 2026: Both parties are gearing up—Lively to prove allegations of harassment and retaliation, and Baldoni aiming to refute them.
This ruling marks a pivotal moment in a deeply personal and high-stakes legal battle, illustrating how private communications—especially between high-profile individuals—can play a significant role in court and affect relationships beyond the courtroom.
